Baldur's Gate 3 GuidesGame Guides

Attack Withers Or Answer His Question In Baldurs Gate 3

You encounter Withers in the Dank Crypt, after finding the secret room and opening the Richly Adorned Sarcophagus. In this guide on Attack Withers Or Answer His Question In Baldurs Gate 3, we’ll explain what happens depending on what choice you decide to make.

This is one of those choices that appear to have similar outcomes, whatever route you choose. There is a chance that the choices will have a greater impact later down the line, but in the immediate aftermath of the situation, Withers does pretty much the same thing.

Attack Withers Or Answer His Question In Baldurs Gate 3

If You Choose To Attack Withers
He will tell you to swing away. I tried multiple attacks. Everything from shove to Magic Missiles, but none of the abilities I had access to did any damage. Every hit was 0. Combat doesn’t actually start and Withers does not retaliate. Even if you try to taunt him during the following dialogue, he will not engage. Withers will eventually leave and promise to see you again.

If You Choose To Answer Withers Question
I chose the first response, No one life is worth more than any other. We are all equal. Withers says he is satisfied with that answer and promises you will meet again. It’s possible that the answer here has an impact later in the game. We’ll update the guide once we reach that part.

Attack Withers Or Answer His Question In Baldurs Gate 3 Video Guide

If you break your oath through an action or choice, you will become an Oathbreaker. In this guide on How To Reclaim Your Broken Oath In Baldur's Gate 3 we'll explain how you can return to your previous form and maintain the skills and abilities you had access to.
After an epic battle with Cazador, you obtain his staff and get to decide the fate of the vampire spawn. In this guide on Kill The Vampire Spawn Or Release Them In Baldur's Gate 3 we'll explain what happens with both choice so you can decide what direction your story wants to go.
The dark magical book provides you with several choices to complete this quest. This The Necromancy Of Thay Book Choices Guide For Baldur's Gate 3 breaks down what happens whether you decide to keep the book, read the book, or give the book away.
Part of the Open Hand Temple Murders quest sees you find a Flowery Key. This guide on Where To Use The Strange Flowery Key In Baldur's Gate 3 will tell you everything you need to know about completing this stage of the quest so you can find the secret entrance, use the Flowery key, and grab your evidence.

Blaine Smith

Blaine "Captain Camper" Smith is one of the original founders of Gamers Heroes. Now operating under the guise of Editor-in-Chief (purely because we felt the position was needed for public relations purposes), he's tasked with a lot of the kind of jobs that would put you to sleep at your desk. When he's not catching some Zs, you'll likely find him arguing points he knows nothing about, playing the latest rogue-like he'll never complete, or breaking something on the website that never needed fixing. You can best reach him on Twitter
Back to top button