Which Scarecrow To Pick In Batman Arkham Knight
During your hunt for Scarecrow you will eventually come up to a puzzle you have to pass. The question is simple enough, the right or the left Scarecrow? Check out this guide to find out which you should pick in Batman Arkham Knight!
Right Or Left Scarecrow In Batman Arkham Knight
When you are rolling up to the two Scarecrows, hallucination Joker will try to make play mind games with you. It is pretty funny if you sit a listen to him use LEFT and RIGHT in the sentences. He will keep going for awhile too if you got some time to kill.
Ultimately the choice doesn’t seem to matter. I choose the left Scarecrow and got blasted by the real one on the right. This seems like a key story moment so I imagine if you pick the right he will actually be on the left. If you can get it right the Scarecrow would be on the right since I got it wrong on the left. Either way you can expect to be blasted by the fear toxin.
After that you will go through a bit of a hallucination and have to fight off some enemies. This all leads up to the confrontation with Scarecrow and the Arkham Knight. After the whole thing is said and done, Scarecrow will broadcast a message to you and the rest of the city.
Allan Marshall left us a comment saying that he picked the right Scarecrow and ended up getting the same result(Thanks). So now you know that it doesn’t really matter which Scarecrow you pick, it is just meant to mess with your mind.

Doesn’t matter, picked right one and got same result
Thanks for the info!
I picked the right one too, assuming the Joker was giving me a hint to pick him since he was saying “To be RIGHT” and “You don’t want to be LEFT behind”. But they could justify that either way. If you picked left, he genuinely was trying to help you, if you pick right, he was trying to get you dosed with fear gas
This “guide” is pointless. Please take it down. Essentially click bait for people wondering if it matters, when you could easily just say; “It makes no difference”.
“PeopleAreStupid” posting a stupid comment…Oh the irony lol
People Google it looking for the answer to the decision they have to make. This post provides an answer to that question. Please return after you figure out how the Internet works! 😉
Picked one on left and got the same result. So CONFIRMED…Doesn’t matter.
Lol this is REALLY late, but I played through again in Knightmare mode and made the opposite choice with the same results, so yeah. Definitely doesn’t matter which one you pick.